A drug recognition expert (DRE) is a New York police officer certified to run a 12-step evaluation after a DWAI-Drugs arrest and name the type of drug behind your impairment, and a blood or urine test then has to back up that opinion. In one of our cases, a client charged with DWI and DWAI-Drugs after a parking lot accident had both charges dismissed once we showed the district attorney that her blood held amphetamine she took under an Adderall prescription and an inactive marijuana metabolite (prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome). The DWI Team, led by former Onondaga County prosecutor and Super Lawyers Top Rated DWI attorney Dennis J. Nave, defends DWAI-Drugs charges in all 62 New York counties for a flat fee, starting with a free case analysis.
DRE evaluations in New York at a glance
- Who: a police officer certified through the Drug Evaluation and Classification Program, which the International Association of Chiefs of Police coordinates and New York’s Governor’s Traffic Safety Committee runs in this state.
- When: after an arrest, when the breath test result does not explain the impairment the arresting officer saw.
- What: 12 standardized steps ending in an opinion that names one or more of seven drug categories.
- Proof: a blood, urine or saliva test within two hours of the arrest, which every driver is deemed to have consented to.
- Refusing the test: a license revocation of at least one year and a $500 civil penalty.
- The charge: DWAI-Drugs under VTL § 1192(4), a misdemeanor with a $500 to $1,000 fine, up to a year in jail and a license revocation of at least six months.
- Which drugs count: only substances listed in Public Health Law § 3306, plus cannabis.
What a Drug Recognition Expert Is
The International Association of Chiefs of Police describes a DRE as a police officer trained to recognize impairment in drivers under the influence of drugs other than, or in addition to, alcohol. The association coordinates the Drug Evaluation and Classification Program with support from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. The protocol began at the Los Angeles Police Department, and New York was one of the four states in NHTSA’s first pilot programs in 1987.
In New York the Governor’s Traffic Safety Committee trains DREs. An officer needs at least two years of police service, two years of experience since completing NHTSA’s field sobriety test training, and the classroom version of Advanced Roadside Impaired Driving Enforcement (ARIDE) within the past five years. Training opens with a two-day pre-school that ends in a field sobriety proficiency exam and a written exam, followed by a seven-day school on physiology, vital signs and the seven drug categories, where every exam requires a score of at least 80 percent.
Field certification comes next. Under the supervision of instructors, the officer completes at least 12 evaluations of people under the influence of drugs, correctly identifies four of the seven drug categories, keeps a progress log and a rolling log, and passes a final knowledge exam at 80 percent. Certification lasts two years, and renewing it takes at least four evaluations in that time, a current rolling log and resume, and 16 hours of approved recertification training.
New York has relatively few of them. The Orchard Park Police Department, which has two DREs, reported that the state had 345 at the end of 2021, fewer than half a percent of its police officers, and that they conducted 2,723 evaluations that year. Orchard Park’s DREs are on call around the clock for their own department and for neighboring agencies, so the DRE in your case may work for a different department than the officer who arrested you.
When Police Call a DRE
A DRE evaluation starts with a breath test. The arresting officer compares the breath result with the impairment seen at the roadside and asks for a DRE when the number does not explain it. The Orchard Park police describe the two usual situations: the driver is plainly impaired and alcohol is not suspected, or the impairment does not fit the known alcohol level, such as a driver who did poorly on the field sobriety tests and then blew a low reading on the breath test.
The evaluation takes place after the arrest, and the charge that follows is DWAI-Drugs under VTL § 1192(4), or DWAI-Combination under § 1192(4-a) when the officer believes alcohol and a drug acted together. Both are misdemeanors carrying a fine of $500 to $1,000 and up to a year in jail, and a conviction revokes your license for at least six months.
The 12 Steps of a DRE Evaluation
The IACP’s description of the protocol calls it standardized because every DRE runs it the same way for every suspect whenever possible, and systematic because it relies on signs an examiner can observe. It answers three questions in order: whether the person is impaired, whether the cause is a drug or a medical condition, and which drug category or combination of categories is the likely cause. The steps are:
- Breath alcohol test. The arresting officer reviews the breath result and asks for a DRE when the number does not account for the impairment.
- Interview of the arresting officer. The DRE goes over the breath result and asks the officer about your driving, your behavior and how you looked.
- Preliminary examination and first pulse. The DRE asks standard questions about your health and what you recently ate, drank or took, including prescriptions, checks whether your pupils are the same size and your eyes track a moving object equally, looks for horizontal gaze nystagmus, and takes your pulse. This step exists to catch an injury or medical condition, and a DRE who suspects a serious one is supposed to stop and get medical help.
- Eye examination. The DRE checks for horizontal and vertical gaze nystagmus and for a lack of convergence, meaning your eyes cannot cross toward your nose.
- Divided attention tests. You perform the Modified Romberg Balance test, the walk and turn, the one leg stand and the finger to nose test.
- Vital signs and second pulse. The DRE takes your blood pressure, temperature and pulse.
- Dark room examination. The DRE estimates your pupil size in three lighting conditions with a measuring device called a pupilometer, to judge whether your pupils are dilated, constricted or normal.
- Muscle tone. The DRE feels your muscles for rigidity or unusual looseness, since some drug categories cause one and some the other.
- Injection sites and third pulse. The DRE looks for injection marks and takes your pulse a final time.
- Your statements. The DRE reads the Miranda warnings if no one has yet and asks about drug use.
- The evaluator’s opinion. From everything recorded, the DRE decides whether you are impaired and, if so, which category or categories of drug caused it.
- Toxicology. A chemical test, usually of blood or urine, is collected to support the opinion.
Every step produces a written entry. New York’s DRE program tracks evaluations in the DRE Data Entry and Management System, built by the Institute for Traffic Safety Management and Research. Its mobile application captures every field of the Drug Influence Evaluation form, along with crash involvement, the driver’s license information and whether the driver holds a medical marijuana card, and the data goes into a statewide database and a national one.
The Seven Drug Categories
DREs sort drugs into seven categories, each defined by the effects its drugs share. The IACP’s category list gives these examples:
| Category | What the drugs do | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Central nervous system depressants | Slow down the brain and body | Alcohol, barbiturates, anti-anxiety drugs such as Xanax and Valium, GHB |
| Central nervous system stimulants | Raise the heart rate and blood pressure | Cocaine, amphetamines, methamphetamine |
| Hallucinogens | Change how the user perceives things | LSD, peyote, psilocybin, MDMA |
| Dissociative anesthetics | Block the brain’s perception of pain | PCP and its analogs, dextromethorphan |
| Narcotic analgesics | Relieve pain and cause euphoria and mood changes | Codeine, heroin, morphine, methadone, Vicodin, OxyContin |
| Inhalants | Breathable substances with mind-altering effects | Toluene, plastic cement, paint, gasoline, paint thinner, hair spray, anesthetic gases |
| Cannabis | THC, the active ingredient in marijuana | Marijuana and synthetic cannabinoids such as dronabinol |
The categories and New York law do not match exactly. Under VTL § 114-a, a drug for DWAI-Drugs purposes is a substance listed in Public Health Law § 3306, plus cannabis and concentrated cannabis. Dextromethorphan, the cough suppressant the IACP lists as a dissociative anesthetic, is absent from that schedule. In People v. Litto (2007), the Court of Appeals explained that a driver who inhaled difluoroethane, the propellant in a can of computer duster, could not have been charged under VTL § 1192(4) because the substance is not on the list, and held that the word intoxicated in the DWI statute refers to alcohol.
Every step of the evaluation is written down.
The DRE’s evaluation form, the toxicology report and the lab’s chain of custody records are the evidence in a DWAI-Drugs case. Tell us what happened during your evaluation, and we will tell you where it can be challenged.
Get a Free Case Analysis → Or call (800) 570-1810, available 24/7 →The Blood or Urine Test After the Evaluation
Step 12 is the only chemical test in the protocol. Under VTL § 1194(2)(a), every driver in New York is deemed to have consented to a chemical test of breath, blood, urine or saliva to measure alcohol or drug content, given at a police officer’s direction within two hours of the arrest. A test given later can be used only if you expressly and voluntarily agreed to it, and the Court of Appeals upheld the suppression of a late test in People v. Odum (2018) because the driver agreed only after inaccurate warnings.
Refusing the chemical test after the warnings leads to a license suspension at arraignment, a revocation of at least one year after a DMV hearing, and a $500 civil penalty, whatever happens to the criminal charge, and the refusal can be used as evidence at trial. Our pages on implied consent in New York and on refusing both breath and drug testing cover that process.
The other eleven steps are examinations and interviews, so declining them carries no automatic revocation. A refusal can still hurt you at trial: the Court of Appeals held in People v. Berg (1999) that a refusal to perform field sobriety tests is admissible evidence, and the four divided attention tests in step 5 are tests of that kind.
When a crash kills or seriously injures someone other than the driver, a judge can order a blood test after a refusal under VTL § 1194(3). Our article on whether police can force a blood test explains when that order is allowed.
Who Can Draw Your Blood
VTL § 1194(4)(a) limits who may draw blood at a police officer’s request. A physician, registered nurse, registered physician assistant, certified nurse practitioner or advanced emergency medical technician certified by the Department of Health can draw it on their own. A licensed clinical laboratory technician or technologist, a phlebotomist, or a medical laboratory technician or medical technologist at an approved clinical laboratory can draw it only under the supervision and direction of a physician, physician assistant or nurse practitioner, or with the express consent of a driver 18 or older. These limits do not cover urine, saliva or breath samples.
Under VTL § 1194(4)(b), you can also choose a physician to give you a chemical test in addition to the one the police ordered. Our article on asking for a blood test covers how that request works.
Chain of Custody and the Toxicology Lab
A blood or urine sample is fungible evidence, meaning one tube looks like another, so the prosecution has to account for it from the moment it is drawn to the moment it is tested. The Court of Appeals held in People v. Julian (1977) that the circumstances must provide reasonable assurances of the identity and unchanged condition of such evidence. In a drug case that means records showing who collected the sample, how the container was sealed and labeled, who carried it to the lab, how it was stored, and who opened and tested it.
The Health Department’s testing rules in 10 NYCRR Part 59 set the methods and analyst permits for measuring alcohol. For drugs, the laboratory has to meet the accreditation program the state Commission on Forensic Science sets under Executive Law § 995-b, which covers minimum standards for forensic labs, qualifications for lab directors and staff, and approval of each lab for specific testing methods.
In discovery, CPL § 245.20(1)(j) requires the prosecution to turn over all reports, records, data and bench notes concerning physical examinations and scientific tests made at the direction of police, which describes both the DRE’s evaluation and the lab’s analysis of your sample. When you are out of custody, that initial discovery is due within 35 days of your arraignment.
Prescription and Over-the-Counter Medication
A valid prescription is no defense to DWAI-Drugs. VTL § 1192(4) covers any listed drug that impairs your ability to drive, and many common prescriptions are on the Public Health Law schedule, including alprazolam (Xanax), clonazepam (Klonopin), zolpidem (Ambien), eszopiclone (Lunesta), oxycodone, hydrocodone, tramadol, carisoprodol (Soma), pregabalin (Lyrica), amphetamine (Adderall) and methylphenidate (Ritalin). Telling the DRE about your prescriptions in step 3 also puts the drug’s name in the report.
Some medications that cause drowsiness are absent from the schedule, among them diphenhydramine, the antihistamine in Benadryl and many over-the-counter sleep aids, the muscle relaxant cyclobenzaprine (Flexeril) and dextromethorphan. Under VTL § 114-a and Litto, impairment from one of those alone cannot support a DWAI-Drugs charge, though alcohol taken with it can still support an alcohol charge.
A positive toxicology result shows that a drug was in your body, and the prosecution still has to prove that the drug impaired your driving. In the case described at the top of this page, we pointed out that the toxicology report could not tell amphetamine taken at the prescribed dose from amphetamine taken beyond it. In another case, a client who blew 0.00 and then agreed to a blood draw was taking his prescription as prescribed, and after we showed the district attorney the problems with the police work, he pleaded to a single traffic ticket for moving from his lane unsafely. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
Our article on DWI charges for prescription and over-the-counter medication covers the medications most often involved, and commercial drivers face their own rules, covered in our page on CDL drivers and prescription drugs.
Cannabis and the DRE Evaluation
VTL § 114-a names cannabis and concentrated cannabis directly, so DWAI-Drugs applies to cannabis whether you used it legally as an adult or under a medical marijuana card. A blood test can show 11-nor-9-carboxy-THC, a metabolite with no psychoactive effect, and in the parking lot case above it was the only cannabis compound in our client’s blood, which suggested she had last used marijuana days earlier. Our pages on marijuana DWI charges in New York and medical marijuana and DWAI go further.
How a DRE Evaluation Is Challenged
The evaluation is an officer’s opinion built from a long list of recorded observations, and each part can be tested against the protocol and the toxicology:
- Certification. Was the DRE certified on the date of your evaluation, with the four evaluations, rolling log and 16 hours of training that renewal requires every two years?
- The steps themselves. Did the DRE complete all 12, record your pulse three times, measure your pupils in all three lighting conditions, and ask about injuries and medical conditions in step 3?
- Whether the signs fit the drug. In our parking lot case, the deputy recorded all six clues on the horizontal gaze nystagmus test, and we pointed out that neither cannabis nor amphetamine causes nystagmus, which suggested the test was given incorrectly.
- The two-hour limit. Was the blood or urine sample taken within two hours of the arrest, and if not, did you expressly agree to a later test?
- Chain of custody and the lab. Do the records account for the sample from collection to testing, and was the lab accredited for the method it used?
Statements you made at the roadside or in step 10 can be challenged at a Huntley hearing, and the stop and arrest themselves at Mapp and Dunaway hearings, which our page on Huntley, Mapp and Dunaway hearings explains. If you were arrested recently, our guide to the first 72 hours after a DWI arrest covers the deadlines that start right away.
Have the DRE’s report reviewed before you decide on a plea.
The DWI Team checks the evaluation, the toxicology and the chain of custody in every drug case, and looks for the plea or dismissal the evidence supports.
Call the DWI Team at (800) 570-1810, any time of day, or request a free case analysis. Our DWI defense attorneys work for a flat fee, with payment plans from $500 down, and can tell you what the DRE’s report and the lab results in your case show.
Frequently Asked Questions About DRE Evaluations in New York
What is a drug recognition expert?
A drug recognition expert, or DRE, is a police officer certified through the Drug Evaluation and Classification Program to recognize impairment by drugs other than, or in addition to, alcohol. In New York the Governor’s Traffic Safety Committee trains DREs, and their certification lasts two years.
What are the 12 steps of a DRE evaluation?
The breath alcohol test, an interview of the arresting officer, a preliminary examination with the first pulse, an eye examination, four divided attention tests, vital signs with the second pulse, a dark room pupil examination, a muscle tone check, a check for injection sites with the third pulse, questions about drug use, the evaluator’s opinion, and a toxicology test of blood or urine.
How long does it take to become a drug recognition expert in New York?
After at least two years of police service, an officer completes a two-day pre-school and a seven-day school, then a field certification phase with at least 12 supervised evaluations and a final exam that requires a score of 80 percent.
Can I refuse a DRE evaluation in New York?
Only the chemical test at the end falls under implied consent, and refusing it brings a license revocation of at least one year and a $500 civil penalty. Declining the other steps carries no automatic revocation, though the Court of Appeals has held that a refusal to perform field sobriety tests can be used at trial.
Can I be charged with DWAI-Drugs for taking my prescription?
Yes. A valid prescription is no defense when the drug is listed in Public Health Law section 3306 and it impaired your ability to drive. Common examples on the list include Xanax, Klonopin, Ambien, oxycodone, hydrocodone, tramadol and Adderall.
Does Benadryl count as a drug for a DWAI-Drugs charge?
Diphenhydramine, the antihistamine in Benadryl, is absent from the Public Health Law schedule that defines a drug for DWAI-Drugs, so impairment from it alone cannot support that charge. Alcohol taken with it can still support an alcohol charge.
Who can draw my blood after a DWI arrest in New York?
A physician, registered nurse, physician assistant, nurse practitioner or advanced emergency medical technician can draw it at a police officer’s request. A phlebotomist or laboratory technician can draw it only under a physician, physician assistant or nurse practitioner’s supervision, or with the express consent of a driver 18 or older.
How long after an arrest can police test me for drugs?
The chemical test every driver is deemed to have consented to must come within two hours of the arrest. A test given later can be used only if you expressly and voluntarily agreed to it.
This page explains New York law in general terms and is not legal advice for your situation. Every case turns on its own facts. Contact the DWI Team to talk with an attorney.