Huntley, Mapp and Dunaway hearings are the three pretrial hearings where a New York judge decides whether the evidence in a DWI case can be used at trial. A Huntley hearing tests the statements you made to police, a Mapp hearing tests evidence taken in a search, and a Dunaway hearing tests whether police had probable cause to arrest you. The DWI Team asks for these hearings in DWI, DWAI and chemical test refusal cases in town, village, city and county courts across all 62 New York counties, for a flat fee that starts with a free case analysis and payment plans from $500 down. Our managing partner, Dennis J. Nave, worked in the Onondaga County District Attorney’s Office and is a Super Lawyers Top Rated DWI attorney, and the firm holds a 4.9 rating across more than 300 reviews from the 10,000+ people it has represented. In one case, our client faced a DWI with a .27 BAC, the officer admitted at the hearings that he saw no traffic infraction before the stop, and the judge suppressed all the evidence and dismissed the case. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
New York’s three suppression hearings at a glance
- Huntley hearing: whether your statements to police were voluntary and lawfully obtained. Named for People v. Huntley, decided by the New York Court of Appeals in 1965.
- Mapp hearing: whether physical evidence came from an unlawful search or seizure. Named for Mapp v. Ohio, decided by the U.S. Supreme Court in 1961.
- Dunaway hearing: whether police had probable cause to arrest you. Named for Dunaway v. New York, a 1979 U.S. Supreme Court case that began with an arrest in Rochester.
- Deadline: the motion asking for them is due within 45 days of arraignment under CPL § 255.20.
- Who decides: the judge, after hearing sworn testimony, with no jury present.
Suppression motions are due 45 days after arraignment.
A motion that is never filed is waived, so the review of the stop, the arrest, your statements and the test has to start early. Tell us what happened and we will tell you which hearings your case supports.
Get a Free Case Analysis → Or call (800) 570-1810, available 24/7 →What a Suppression Hearing Decides
A suppression hearing is a short proceeding before trial where the judge decides whether a piece of evidence was obtained lawfully. If it was not, the judge orders it excluded from the case. Criminal Procedure Law § 710.20 lists the grounds, and four of them come up in DWI cases:
- physical evidence taken in an unlawful search or seizure,
- a statement you made involuntarily, as CPL § 60.45 defines that term,
- any evidence police found because of one of those violations, and
- a blood test taken in violation of the court-order rules in VTL § 1194(3).
The New York courts list Mapp, Huntley, Wade and Dunaway hearings as the common suppression hearings, and their guide to the pretrial stage notes that a Dunaway hearing is always held together with one of the others. A Wade hearing tests an eyewitness identification, which seldom comes up in a DWI case, where the arresting officer is usually the main witness. In practice the hearings run as one session, often called a Huntley/Mapp/Dunaway hearing, where the arresting officer testifies about the stop, the arrest, the search and everything you said.
Under CPL § 710.60(4), every witness at the hearing testifies under oath, hearsay is allowed, and the judge must make findings of fact. The judge then states the findings, the conclusions of law and the reasons for the ruling on the record.
The Huntley Hearing: Your Statements to Police
A Huntley hearing decides whether the prosecution can use what you said to police. In a DWI case that usually means answers at the car window such as “I had two beers,” what you said during the roadside tests, and anything you said at the station or in the patrol car. The hearing takes its name from People v. Huntley, where the Court of Appeals ruled that the judge must find a statement voluntary beyond a reasonable doubt before a jury can hear it, and that the burden of proving voluntariness is on the prosecution.
Under CPL § 60.45, a statement is involuntary when it was obtained by force or threats, by improper pressure that undermined your ability to choose whether to speak, by a promise that created a real risk of a false admission, or in violation of your rights under the New York or U.S. Constitution. That last ground is where Miranda warnings come in.
A Miranda violation keeps out the statements you made while in custody and being questioned. It leaves the rest of the case in place. Most DWI evidence, including the officer’s observations, the field sobriety tests and the breath test, is gathered before any custodial questioning, so the case usually goes forward without the statements. Our article on admitting to drinking at a DWI stop explains why those early answers matter.
The notice the prosecution must give
CPL § 710.30 requires the prosecution to tell you, within 15 days after arraignment, that it intends to use a statement you made to a police officer, and to say which statement. If it never serves that notice, the statement cannot be used at trial unless you moved to suppress it anyway and lost. A late notice is allowed only for good cause, and it gives you a new chance to move to suppress.
The Mapp Hearing: Evidence From a Search
A Mapp hearing decides whether physical evidence was taken in an unlawful search or seizure. It is named for Mapp v. Ohio, where the U.S. Supreme Court held that all evidence obtained in a search or seizure that violates the Constitution is inadmissible in a state court. In a DWI case the evidence at issue is usually an open container or drugs found in the car, a search of your pockets, or a blood sample.
Blood draws have their own rule. When a driver refuses a chemical test, police can test blood only by getting a court order under VTL § 1194(3), and CPL § 710.20(5) makes a blood test taken in violation of that subdivision a ground for suppression. Our article on whether police can force a blood test covers when a court order is required.
The Dunaway Hearing: Whether Police Had Grounds to Stop and Arrest You
A Dunaway hearing decides whether police had probable cause to arrest you. The case behind the name, Dunaway v. New York, began in Rochester, where police took a man to the station for questioning without probable cause. The U.S. Supreme Court held in 1979 that this violated the Fourth and Fourteenth Amendments, and that the statements he gave after Miranda warnings still could not be used, because the illegal arrest led directly to them.
In a DWI case the same hearing usually tests two separate steps. An officer needs reasonable suspicion of a traffic violation or a crime to pull you over, as our article on whether police can stop you at random for DWI explains, and needs probable cause to arrest you. When either step fails, the breath test, the blood test, the field sobriety tests and the officer’s later observations can all be suppressed, because police found them as a result of the unlawful stop or arrest.
In People vs. MH, the officer testified at the hearings that he stopped our client’s car as a welfare check, with no traffic infraction, and the judge ruled the stop unlawful, suppressed all the evidence and dismissed a DWI with a .27 BAC. In People vs. LW, a client with a prior DWI and an alleged refusal at a roadblock, the prosecution offered a reduction to a non-alcohol traffic infraction after the suppression hearing. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
Chemical Test Issues Raised Before Trial
Several rules about the chemical test are tested in the same pretrial stage:
- The test you are deemed to consent to under VTL § 1194(2)(a) is tied to an arrest, and the statute sets a two-hour limit measured from the time you were placed under arrest.
- A refusal can be used against you at trial only if the prosecution shows you were warned of its effect in clear and unequivocal language and still refused, under VTL § 1194(2)(f). Our page on implied consent in New York explains the warning.
- A breath result depends on the instrument’s calibration and maintenance records, which the prosecution must turn over in discovery, and our article on breathalyzer tests covers the instrument itself.
When the Motion Has to Be Filed
Suppression hearings start with a written motion. Under CPL § 255.20, pretrial motions are due within 45 days after arraignment, and the deadline moves to 45 days after the prosecution’s statement notice when that notice comes later. The motion has to state its grounds and include sworn allegations of fact under CPL § 710.60(1).
- The judge must grant the motion without a hearing if the prosecution concedes the facts in it, or agrees not to use the evidence.
- The judge may deny it without a hearing if the sworn facts would not support suppression even if true. That shortcut is unavailable for a motion about your statements, so a Huntley challenge to an involuntary statement gets a hearing when the papers state a legal ground.
- Trial cannot start until the motion is decided, under CPL § 710.40(3).
- A suppression issue that is never raised is waived under CPL § 710.70(3).
- If the motion is denied, the ruling can still be appealed after a guilty plea, under CPL § 710.70(2).
The officer has to explain the stop, the arrest and the test under oath.
At a Huntley, Mapp or Dunaway hearing, the testimony is measured against the video, the reports and the calibration records. The DWI Team prepares every hearing from the discovery before you decide anything about a plea.
Discovery: What the Prosecution Has to Hand Over
A suppression motion is only as good as the evidence behind it, and that evidence comes from discovery. Under CPL § 245.10, the prosecution must turn over its initial discovery within 35 calendar days after arraignment when you are out of custody, or within 20 days when you are held, with up to 30 more days allowed for large amounts of video or material it does not yet have. CPL § 245.20(1) lists what it must share, and in a DWI case the most important items are:
- every written or recorded statement you made to police, and the substance of every oral one,
- police reports and officers’ notes, including statements by the witnesses who will testify at the pretrial hearings,
- every recording, including dashcam and body camera video and 911 calls, with the prosecution saying which ones it plans to use at trial or at a hearing,
- any information that tends to show you are not guilty, weakens a witness, or gives a basis for a motion to suppress, and
- the calibration, certification, inspection, repair and maintenance records of the breath or blood testing instrument, for six months before and six months after your test.
Once it has turned everything over, the prosecution files a certificate of compliance, and under CPL § 245.50(3) it cannot be ready for trial for speedy trial purposes until it files a valid one. That ties discovery to the 90-day speedy trial deadline for a misdemeanor DWI that our article on how DWI charges get dismissed explains. When evidence is turned over late, or lost, CPL § 245.80 lets the judge give more time, reopen a hearing, tell the jury it may draw an adverse inference, keep testimony or evidence out, or, as a last resort, dismiss charges.
Rosario material: the officer’s earlier statements
In People v. Rosario, decided in 1961, the Court of Appeals gave the defense the right to see a prosecution witness’s earlier statements about the subject of their testimony, whether or not they differ from what the witness says on the stand. Today CPL § 245.20(1)(e) makes those statements part of automatic discovery, including the statements of officers who will testify at the pretrial hearings. At a Huntley/Mapp/Dunaway hearing, the arresting officer’s notes, reports and earlier testimony are compared line by line with what the officer says under oath.
Dashcam and body camera video
Video is often the most objective evidence in a DWI case. The defense reviews it for contradictions with the officer’s report, for steps the officer skipped, such as the observation period before a breath test, and for conditions like uneven pavement or poor lighting during the field sobriety tests. When there is no video, the prosecution can still rely on the officer’s sworn testimony and the test results, and the defense can argue that testimony with nothing to back it deserves closer scrutiny.
What Happens When Evidence Is Suppressed
When the judge grants the motion, the evidence is excluded from the case under CPL § 710.70(1). A suppressed breath or blood test can leave the prosecution without proof of your BAC, and a suppressed stop can take every piece of evidence with it, which is how the hearings in People vs. MH ended in a dismissal. A hearing that does not end in suppression still puts the officer’s account on the record under oath, which shapes the plea negotiations and any trial that follows. Our article on signs a DWI case is weak covers other weaknesses the hearing can expose.
Talk With a Lawyer Before the Motion Deadline
The 45-day motion deadline starts at your arraignment, and the discovery that supports a suppression motion takes time to obtain and review. Call the DWI Team at (800) 570-1810, any time of day, or request a free case analysis, and our DWI defense attorneys will tell you which hearings your case supports.
Frequently Asked Questions About DWI Suppression Hearings in New York
What is the purpose of a Huntley hearing?
A Huntley hearing decides whether the prosecution can use the statements you made to police. The judge must find a statement voluntary beyond a reasonable doubt, and the prosecution carries that burden. A statement obtained by force, improper pressure, a misleading promise or a violation of your constitutional rights, including Miranda, can be suppressed.
What is a Mapp hearing in New York?
A Mapp hearing decides whether physical evidence was taken in an unlawful search or seizure. In a DWI case it usually concerns items found in the car or on you, or a blood sample. Evidence the judge finds was obtained unlawfully is excluded from the case.
What is a Dunaway hearing in NY?
A Dunaway hearing decides whether police had probable cause to arrest you. It is always held together with a Huntley, Mapp or Wade hearing, and in a DWI case it usually also tests whether the officer had reasonable suspicion to stop your car. When the stop or the arrest was unlawful, the evidence police found because of it can be suppressed.
Can a DWI be dismissed after a suppression hearing?
Yes. When the judge suppresses the stop, the arrest or the chemical test, the prosecution may be left without the evidence it needs, and the case can be dismissed. In one of our cases, the judge ruled the stop unlawful, suppressed all the evidence and dismissed a DWI with a .27 BAC. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
Will my DWI be dismissed if the officer did not read me my Miranda rights?
Usually the case continues. A Miranda violation keeps out the statements you made while in custody and being questioned, and most DWI evidence, including the officer’s observations, the field sobriety tests and the breath test, is gathered before custodial questioning begins.
When do suppression motions have to be filed in New York?
Pretrial motions are due within 45 days after arraignment under CPL 255.20, and the deadline moves to 45 days after the prosecution’s notice of your statements when that notice comes later. A suppression issue that is never raised is waived.
What is discovery in a DWI case?
Discovery is the evidence the prosecution must turn over to the defense, usually within 35 days after arraignment when you are out of custody. In a DWI case it includes your statements, the police reports and notes, dashcam and body camera video, 911 calls, the test results and the testing instrument’s calibration and maintenance records for six months before and after your test.
This page explains New York law in general terms and is not legal advice for your situation. Every case turns on its own facts. Contact the DWI Team to talk with an attorney.